What is interesting about doing these critiques week in and week out is you never know how you will react to a set. Sometimes you have killer image after killer image after killer image. Other times you are stuck with mediocre images with the surprise of one solid image.
I think this set falls in between, the images are not bad but not great. They are simply very very close, they are on the cusp of being something more.
This is a good position to be in for the photographer as there is some major potential with some slight tweaks to take their images to the next level.